3 Lessons From The Best Company In The Worst Industry
6 Comments Latest comment by: Josh Thomson
reddit
|
digg it!
|
del.icio.us
This company has achieved 32 consecutive years of profitability in an industry that regularly loses billions of dollars. It is valued higher than all of its major competitors combined. While its competitors go bankrupt with alarming regularity, this company keeps on growing. Can you guess which company we're talking about?

This Is No Peanuts!
More than 34 years ago, in Texas, two guys named Rollin King and Herb Kelleher decided to start an airline. They began with a simple idea: If they get their passengers to their destinations on time, at the lowest possible fare - people will fly their airline.
What began as their little Texas airline has grown to become one of the largest and certainly the most successful airline in the U.S. They have reinvented the way an airline business is operated with innovations such as point-to-point flights, no assigned seatings, high-frequency/short-haul routes - and of course, the famous peanuts instead of meals!
In 1992, Southwest became the first airline in history to win the annual Triple Crown - Best On-time Record, Best Baggage Handling, and Fewest Customer Complaints - a feat no other airline had been able to match in a single month! Since then, they have won the annual Triple Crown many more times. But that is not all.
In the last year, Southwest achieved bottom-line profits of more than US$500 million - this was higher than the combined profits of all the major carriers in the entire airline industry in the U.S. Surely, this is no peanuts!

What Can We Learn From Southwest?
I believe Southwest Airlines has a lot to teach product management and product marketing professionals in the high-tech industry. The top three lessons, in my opinion, are:
- Think Different:
- In an industry where every major airline operated in the hub-and-spoke model, Southwest went with the point-to-point model. While all the major carriers used assigned seating and preferred long-haul routes, Southwest again went against the grain. In a nutshell, Southwest dared to think different to provide unique value to their customers.
- Lesson:
- Don't just settle for an established way of doing things - whether it is feature set or pricing models.
- Don't fall for "That is the way every one in our industry does it".
- Find a different, better way and provide unique value to your target market - a value that will create loyal customers.
- Focus - Do One Thing Well:
- Southwest's express goal is to be the leading shorthaul, low-fare, high-frequency carrier in America. They have a laser focus on achieving that goal and don't get distracted by trying to be all things to all people. They are willing to sacrifice those travelers (including some of my friends!) who will never fly Southwest since they prefer assigned seatings, first class section, full meals, etc.
- Lesson:
- Carefully pick a well-defined target market for your product and a compelling value proposition for that target market.
- Then focus on delivering that value for that market. Don't get distracted by trying to be all things to all people - usually resulting in feature bloat, confusing product messaging, etc.
- Teamwork:
- Kelleher says his days playing high school football and basketball taught him how a team should work.
- Lesson:
- In most companies, a key responsibility of Product Management and Product Marketing is to lead cross-functional product teams. Make it a high priority to create and foster team spirit in your product teams by clearly communicating the product vision and getting buy-in from every one.
- Lead by example by assisting in areas outside your normal job functions whenever possible.
If you play football, you don't say to the tackle, 'That's your territory, I'm not going to make that tackle.' Teams don't function effectively under those circumstances - Team play is a fundamental concept, and playing team sports brings that home to you very strongly. If you want to succeed, if you want to win, you have to play as a team.
Flying In The Face of Conventional Wisdom
Southwest has achieved incredible success by focusing on seemingly simple goals - but many of which go against the so-called "conventional wisdom". Kelleher says:
The... thing that was important was not accepting the conventional wisdom that it wouldn't work. I think probably only one in four people in Texas thought Southwest had a chance of flying, much less of being successful. I say, 'If it's conventional, it ain't wisdom, and if it's wisdom, it's not conventional.' (emphasis added)
Don't fall prey to the conventional wisdom in your own marketplace - ignore comments like "But all our competitors have those features" or "But that is the only pricing model in our industry ". Think unconventionally to find ways to set your products apart and achieve success in your marketplace.
When you do achieve this success, go ahead and treat yourself to some Wild Turkey, Kelleher's most favorite drink - and send me a bottle too!
About the Author: I'm your author, Michael Shrivathsan, an expert in product management and product marketing with successful experience spanning two decades. I live in Silicon Valley, USA. For my day job, I manage the product management group at an exciting software startup.
Comments
US airline industry is definitely a bad industry. The US steel industry may be even worse. Southwest is certainly a good case study, so is Nucor which is the equivalent in the steel industry.
Posted by: Yuen Li | March 25, 2006 01:59 AM
Southwest is so well managed, they were the only national airline who didn't ask for government handouts after the September 11, 2001 attacks which is as bad an event as any that can be imagined for the airline industry. They do have a lot to teach other businesses, including High Tech. Especially in thinking differently, against the conventional wisdom and innovating in business processes. Thanks for highlighting practical lessons for product managers.
Posted by: Raj Pandi | March 25, 2006 12:45 PM
The point about focusing on the chosen target market is an excellent one. In my past companies, I've repeatedly received requests for all kinds of features from sales just because of competitors have them, even though those features are not very helpful at all to our chosen target market.
More often than not, those features get implemented due to pressures from management resulting in a product that is much harder to use for customers in our target market. Companies that are able to focus on their target market, and willing to forego another section of the market, as Southwest has done, should be commended.
Posted by: Josh Thomson | March 26, 2006 04:28 PM
Thinking different is not always better. Sometimes "conventional wisdom" is so because it is time tested & proven wisdom; such as "Cash is king". Eyeballs, RSS subscriptions and other goofy metrics don't replace old fashioned cash flow; never will. When going against "conventional wisdom" you better tread lightly.
Posted by: Richard Rajeck | March 29, 2006 01:56 AM
I agree that SWA is doing a great job focusing on their target market and their unique value proposition (UVP). Many software companies, especially startups would be well advised to pay notice. It seems in most software companies there are a lot of features added to make sure the software can meet the needs of every customer. This results in software that is pretty bloated and very frustrating to to use.
Posted by: Deepak | April 2, 2006 01:28 PM
Richard -
You're right, some "conventional wisdom" is indeed very true and we're better off following it. In my experience though, I'd say only 5-10% of the so-called "conventional wisdom" falls into this category.
Especially in high tech, you have to go against the grain. Think of Dell deciding to sell direct even though all PC vendors sold through retail channels. Even outside high tech, this is true. For example, Walmart deciding to open stores in smaller towns even though all other major stores operated in large cities. Big successes are created by thinking against conventional wisdom, not with it. My 2 cents.
Posted by: Josh Thomson | April 6, 2006 11:06 AM